Trained Panel Screening and Development

Trained Panel Screening and Development

Overview

A trained descriptive analysis (DA) panel is one of the most powerful sensory tools. A well-trained DA panel gives you the ability to gain deeper insights into your products for the purpose of understanding where they fit in the marketplace, competitive analysis, quality control practices, etc.

This workflow is meant to assist you and your team in the first step of establishing your DA panel – panelist screening. Recruiting panelists that are capable, reliable, and meet all of your criteria, will help to ensure that the quality of your results is not compromised.

Please reach out to Compusense Support if you require the panelist screening tests mentioned throughout this workflow.

Screening Goals

  1. Pre-screen (telephone interview) individuals who are interested in becoming a trained panelist.

  2. Identify up to 40 individuals to screen, based upon their responses to the pre-screening telephone interview.

  3. Select 12 to 15 qualified individuals to join the trained panel.

  4. During the screening process, after each activity you can assign points to panelists to give them a final score after all screening to decide if the panelist will be included in the trained panel.

  5. If none of the selected panelists pass the screening, revisit the original list in order to identify individuals you may have overlooked.

Screening Objectives

To identify panelists who are able to:
  1. Follow instructions.

  2. Communicate and interact within a group setting and also work independently.

  3. Learn attributes after exposure to reference standards.

  4. Describe sensory attributes within various products.

  5. Discriminate visual, aroma, flavour and texture attributes within various products.

Panel Email Advertisement

Email all individuals within your company’s consumer panel database. You can import panelists with emails into the Compusense Panelist database. Another option is a Compusense application form where prospective panelists complete a simple application form to collect demographic information. Use your company’s social media accounts to advertise.

Example of email statement of requirements to include:
  1. Define trained panelist role.

  2. Occasional work (not permanent position), for which individuals are invited to participate.

  3. Flexible to participate in panels between 9am-5pm, week days.

  4. Non-smoker.

  5. No allergies or sensitivities.

  6. Must be at least 19 years old.

  7. Must pass a screening to become a trained panelist.

Pre-screening – Telephone Interview

Individuals who are interested in becoming a trained panelist can be pre-screened with a telephone interview.

Below is an example template that may be used for a pre-screening telephone interview:



Identify Individuals to be Screened

  1. Review phone interview notes.

  2. Identify individuals to be invited to screening activities.

Scheduling (Example)

  1. Invite individuals who passed the pre-screening to participate in screening activities.

  2. Individuals must participate in all necessary screening sessions. It is beneficial to run a morning and afternoon session to confirm potential panelists can attend both times. For example: Session #1 Tuesday - 9:30-11:30, Session #2 Thursday - 1:00-3:00.

  3. Use Compusense to email participants. The Compusense scheduling feature can also be used to schedule screening sessions.

The following links will take you to the pages that outline examples of what two days of screening sessions may look like.

Example: Panelist Screening: Session 1


Example Panelist Screening: Session 2



    • Related Articles

    • Panelist Screening: Session 2

      Overview This page provides the details of the second example session for the Trained Panel Screening and Development process. If you have not reviewed the first session yet, we recommend doing that before reviewing the session 2. Introductions and ...

    • Panelist Screening: Session 1

      Overview This page provides the details of the first example session for the Trained Panel Screening and Development process. If you have not done so already, please visit the introduction page before reading the session 1 workflow. Panelist ...

    • Descriptive Analysis Workbook Panel Performance Summary

      What is it? Panel Performance Summary is one of the sheets in the Descriptive Analysis Workbook . An overview of your panel and panelist performance based on five areas that may be of interest: Standard Deviation, Crossover, Discrimination, Scale ...

    • Manage Panel Membership

      Overview Your panelists in the Panelists library must be members of at least one panel. In this workflow you will learn how to manage all aspects of panel membership. Before you can change panel membership for panelists, the panels and subpanels in ...

    • Add/Delete/Rename a Panel

      Overview Before you can use panelists in your tests, they need to exist in the Panelists library. Before you can import or manually add panelists into the Panelists library, first you will need to have a panel to add panelists into. All panelists in ...